Eileen's Special Cheesecake

17 Cleveland Pl, New York City

4.5
  • Phone Numbers: 12129665585
  • Address: 17 Cleveland Pl, New York City
  • Meals: Late Night
  • Restaurant features: Takeout, Seating, Accepts American Express, Accepts Mastercard, Accepts Visa, Accepts Discover, Delivery, Reservations, Accepts Credit Cards
  • Good for: Families with children, Kids, Local cuisine
  • Websites:

click on map to see in full size

Open Hours:

  • Mon

    09:00 - 21:00

  • Tue

    09:00 - 21:00

  • Wed

    09:00 - 21:00

  • Thu

    09:00 - 21:00

  • Fri

    09:00 - 21:00

  • Sat

    10:00 - 19:00

  • Sun

    10:00 - 19:00

Plan Your Visit to New York City

Destination

Create new trip

{{ loadingMessage }}

Reviews

  • Ji Hun Cha

    4
    - 11 September 2018 -

    Small place with friendly people! I am not a fan of sweets, but my wife is. Plus, how can you not try cheesecake if you’re in New York? Cakes were pretty good. I only tried the plain cheesecake, but there are dozen more flavors that you can choose from. I thought the cakes were a bit small considering the price. Overall, good experience. After all, they made me finish the cake as I usually end up not finishing sweets.

  • Andrew Jung

    5
    - 09 September 2018 -

    I have been returning to Elieen's Special Cheesecake for the past eight years. Personally, I have no doubt they serve the best cheesecake in America! However, I recently noticed a significant price increase.

  • Abdul Kadar Bookwala

    4
    - 06 September 2018 -

    This was my first visit to NYC and I am a real foodie. Visited Eileen Special Cheesecake and found it real amazing. The staff is very welcoming and pleasant. We had a pineapple cheesecake which was amazing and raspberry cheesecake. I would rate the staff as 10/10. The cheesecake for the price would be 8/10. 8 is pretty good the way I rate it. So it’s a must have.

  • Heidi Adia

    5
    - 12 July 2018 -

    Light and delicious cheesecake in a variety of flavors. Sizes range from mini to full on cakes at reasonable pricing. I ordered the original and strawberry topped mini cheesecake. Location is small and it can get busy with the lineup at times (we didn’t have an issue), but it’s not that long of a wait.

  • Michelle Kaewchandee

    5
    - 06 June 2018 -

    Perfect for the cheesecake lover in your life! Great selection of mini bites to full on birthday cheesecakes. Prices are reasonable & definitely worth it! Best to get down here early in the day so you know you’re getting the best selection of cakes especially if you are looking for something specific. Will order from them again soon!

  • Ben Hsiang

    5
    - 06 April 2018 -

    DELICIOUS cheesecake and chocolate cake. You can tell they use quality ingredients. Cheesecake was just the right consistency- light and creamy. I’m not a big fan of chocolate cake but I would eat Eileen’s chocolate layered cake any day.

  • Christine Moellering

    5
    - 01 April 2018 -

    We wandered around in the rain for several hours on this rainy February Thursday and it was so fun to discover this tiny shop with the best cheesecake I have ever eaten! Major bonus were the amazing employees who were so friendly and fun. I seriously cannot wait to go back someday in the future and get more cheesecake! Best ever!

  • Lilith Moellering

    5
    - 01 April 2018 -

    We wandered around for a long while on this rainy day in February. Then we found this place and I had read it was a great place to get NY style cheesecake. I think it may have been my favorite dessert on the whole trip. PLUS the employees made it so much better. Delish and a fun conversation. What a treat. I can't wait to come back!

  • Ciler Erbil

    2
    - 29 March 2018 -

    I will not trust reviews on websites anymore. There is nothing special about these cheesecakes. Way too expensive, they are small, don't taste or even look good. Just regular cheesecake nothing special. Too sweet, the one with berries, the berries are not fresh, just sticky jam. And the place definitely needs renovation! Come on what are those cheap plastic flowers in front of the window?

  • Duron Tires

    5
    - 21 March 2018 -

    The best cheesecake hands down! I was just there on Monday visiting from Houston, and she packed 3 cheesecakes for me to travel home with. They still taste just as amazing as the ones in store!

Nearby Things to Do in New York City

Tenement Museum

The Tenement Museum was founded in 1988. It is a National Historic Site. The museum's exhibits and programs include restored apartments and shops, depicting the lives of immigrants, such as Irish and Italian Catholic and European Jewish families. It was home to 7,000 people from 20 nations.

SoHo
SoHo
4.5

SoHo is a neighborhood in Lower Manhattan, which in recent history came to the public's attention for being the location of many artists' lofts and art galleries, but is now better known for its variety of shops ranging from trendy upscale boutiques to national and international chain store outlets.

Greenwich Village

Greenwich Village is a neighborhood on the west side of Lower Manhattan, which has been known as an artists' haven, the Bohemian capital and the cradle of the modern LGBT movement. Historically, local residents have been concerned about development and its architectural and historic integrity.

{{ loadingMessage }}