Pizza Suprema

413 8th Ave, New York City

4.5

click on map to see in full size

Open Hours:

  • Mon

    10:30 - 00:00

  • Tue

    10:30 - 00:00

  • Wed

    10:30 - 00:00

  • Thu

    10:30 - 00:00

  • Fri

    10:30 - 00:00

  • Sat

    10:30 - 00:00

  • Sun

    10:30 - 00:00

Plan Your Visit to New York City

Destination

Create new trip

{{ loadingMessage }}

Reviews

  • ReKhafre Ankh

    5
    - 06 September 2018 -

    I have eaten there since 1995. The pizza taste the same today as it did when I took my very first bite! You can taste bits of tomato in the sauce.the sauce is not bitter or sweet. You can taste the Italian spices in every bite. I can honestly say when you eat Supreme Pizza. You taste a bit of history and a bit of Italy.

  • Mark Russo

    2
    - 24 August 2018 -

    Did all these people with the 5 stars go to the same place? Or maybe compared to the other tourist traps in the area, this was the best that tourists experienced? I've been here 4 or 5 times because it is convenient and I was told it was some of the best pizza in NY. What a joke. Maybe it used to be good? Too much sauce and the sauce is too sweet. Very inconsistent as well. Quality seems on par with dollar slice places. I'm guessing this place used to be good but the owners are just cashing out now.

  • Abhishek Haksar

    5
    - 03 August 2018 -

    Great Pizza's, definitely the classic NYC pizza place ambience. There's a lot going for this place. The food's great, just a walking distance from MSG. Go for the buffalo chicken, Sicilian or the Grandma Pizza. All of them are great. If you're a little bit confused about what to order ask the staff they are very helpful would give you recommendations about which pizza's to order.

  • lois hoffman

    5
    - 21 July 2018 -

    Pizza was great. Waitress forgot our water twice but I am being nice because it was very busy. We tried thin crust and the deep pan pizza with sausage, peppers, and onions. It was very good. I can see why this place has such business. The wait for my husband and I was around 40 minutes on a Saturday, mid-day. I recommend the thin crust.

  • Justin Canillas

    5
    - 27 June 2018 -

    Hot Honey is one of the most amazing if not the best slices I've ever had. Made with homemade ricotta and mozzarella cheeses topped with Mushroom, and drizzled with Hot Honey. Cheese is cooked enough to melt in your mouth without ruining it's structural integrity. The Hot Honey adds a great sweetness while sneaking in a good taste of spiciness. The crust is just too perfect. I would say this slice is best accompanied with their margarita slice.

  • Hollie Erickson

    2
    - 09 April 2018 -

    Really wanted to like this and had high expectations but was so disappointed. I feel like there should be some disclaimer that the pizza sauce is SWEET...which I know some people like but if you're not expecting it it's pretty off-putting. Also the cheese had almost a smoky flavor...not a fan. Crust was very good though and delivery was quick.

  • Surafel Meressa

    5
    - 28 March 2018 -

    The pizza is delicious. We had Pizza Grandma and margarita. It's one of the best pizza we ate. They also have a vegan and vegetarian option. They don't have big space and no parking. Restroom Is limited to only one so you make sure to come refreshed. We highly recommend NY pizza Suprema for pizza lovers who came to NYC. The taste is amazing !

  • Mark Wilkin

    5
    - 26 March 2018 -

    Great pizza made with real ingredients. Great to be able to mix and match so many options by the slice. Conveniently located near MSG and Penn station, I go here every time I take Amtrak to NYC. In 3 minutes your order is ready. I especially like the meat lovers or meatball pizza but the white is tasty as well. It sometimes gets crowded but seats always open up quickly. Don't miss this New York landmark.

  • Vi Tran

    5
    - 16 March 2018 -

    Busy busy busy! But oh so good! I enjoyed eating my pizza there and everything was cooked to perfection. I’m from Texas so the ordering was kinda confusing to me, but I got my pizza, so it was okay. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for good pizza in New York!

  • Matthew Howard

    5
    - 13 February 2018 -

    Crowded noisy fast paces pizza place! Its the best! If you're looking for some quality New York pizza, this is the place! I always take friends not from the area here to get a good quality selection and pizza that is awesome. The dough is great. Good seasoning and good crunch. The sauce is top notch and the toppings are plentiful.

Nearby Things to Do in New York City

Empire State Building

The Empire State Building is a 102-story skyscraper located on Fifth Avenue. It has a roof height of 443.2 m. The Empire State Building is an American cultural icon. It is designed in the distinctive Art Deco style and has been named as one of the Seven Wonders of the Modern World.

Manhattan Skyline

Manhattan skyline is the group of the tallest and the most iconic skyscrapers in New York. Situated in midtown, Manhattan, the skyline became so popular, that its magnificent view symbolizes the whole New York city. The skyline includes the world known Empire State Building and Rockfeller Center.

Madison Square Garden

Madison Square Garden is a multi-purpose indoor arena in the New York. The Garden is used for professional basketball and ice hockey, as well as boxing, concerts, ice shows, circuses, professional wrestling and other forms of sports and entertainment.

{{ loadingMessage }}